How Chicago Small Businesses Can Compete Online
FW16 USA
The Chicago Competitive Reality
Chicago is dense and competitive: thousands of small businesses, plus national chains with big ad budgets, all fighting to show up for the same “near me” and neighborhood searches.
Key dynamics you’re up against:
National brands run constant paid ads and have strong domain authority.
Local competitors are also trying to rank for “plumber near me,” “best tacos Chicago,” and similar broad phrases.
Search results heavily feature Google Maps, reviews, and directories—so visibility is not just about your website.
Where small businesses have an advantage:
Proximity and relevance: Google often prioritizes nearby, clearly local businesses over big brands in Maps and “near me” searches.
Authentic reviews and community presence: Strong local ratings can outrank better-known brands.
Hyperlocal, specific content: You can target “Logan Square,” “Pilsen,” “Ravenswood,” etc., in ways national chains never will.
Why Long-Tail + Local Intent Is Your Power Move
Instead of fighting over “Chicago plumber” or “Chicago restaurant,” you focus on long-tail phrases: more words, more specific, less competition, and much higher intent.
Examples of long-tail local searches (exactly where you can win):
“same day plumber in Logan Square Chicago”
“best family-owned Italian restaurant Wicker Park”
“small business tax accountant near Pilsen”
“vegan brunch in Lakeview Chicago open Sunday”
“emergency boiler repair Bridgeport Chicago”
“after-school tutoring in Bronzeville for ACT prep”
Why these work for you:
They match how real people search on mobile (“best brunch spot in Logan Square”).
They reveal clear intent—someone searching “emergency plumber near Humboldt Park” is ready to call now.
Big chains often don’t create pages for specific neighborhoods or situations; you can.
How to Find Your Best Long-Tail Local Keywords
You don’t need fancy tools to start; you can do 80% of this with Google and what you know about your customers.
Step 1: Start with your core services
List what you actually sell or do, in plain language:
Restaurant: “tacos,” “family-friendly brunch,” “date night,” “BYOB Italian”
Home services: “drain cleaning,” “water heater repair,” “24/7 emergency plumbing”
Professional services: “LLC setup,” “divorce lawyer,” “small business bookkeeping”
Step 2: Add Chicago + neighborhoods
Pair each service with:
“Chicago”
Your nearest neighborhoods (Logan Square, Wicker Park, Pilsen, Hyde Park, Rogers Park, Bronzeville, West Loop, Lincoln Park, etc.)
Nearby landmarks or hubs (“near DePaul University,” “near United Center,” “near UIC,” “near McCormick Place”)
Example expansions:
“deep dish pizza Lincoln Park Chicago”
“mexican restaurant near Pilsen Chicago with patio”
“emergency electrician West Loop Chicago 24 hour”
“estate planning attorney near Hyde Park Chicago”
Step 3: Layer in qualifiers that show intent
Add words that reflect what people care about most:
Price: “affordable,” “cheap,” “fair priced”
Audience: “family-friendly,” “for small businesses,” “for students,” “for seniors”
Timing: “same day,” “24/7,” “open late,” “open Sunday”
Style/fit: “woman-owned,” “LGBTQ-friendly,” “Latino-owned,” “eco-friendly,” “kid-friendly”
Examples:
“affordable plumber in Logan Square Chicago”
“best family-owned restaurant Wicker Park”
“woman-owned small business accountant near Pilsen”
“LGBTQ-friendly therapist near Andersonville Chicago”
Step 4: Use Google’s hints
Type your phrase into Google and look at:
Autocomplete suggestions as you type.
“People also ask” questions.
“Related searches” at the bottom.
These show real phrases people use, which you can reuse on your pages and Google Business Profile.
Mapping Keywords to the Customer Journey
Think about your customer’s journey in three stages and match content to each.
1) Awareness (they know the problem, not the provider)
Search behavior:
“why does my sink keep backing up”
“how to choose a divorce lawyer in Chicago”
“best neighborhoods in Chicago for vintage shopping”
Content ideas:
Short guides or blog posts: “How to Choose the Right Plumber in Logan Square (Without Overpaying).”
FAQs: “What does an emergency plumbing visit cost in Chicago?”
Neighborhood guides: “Best brunch spots in Wicker Park for families.”
2) Consideration (they’re comparing options)
Search behavior:
“Top brunch spots Wicker Park”
“best small business accountant Chicago reviews”
“Pilsen cleaning services monthly”
Content ideas:
Service pages optimized for each neighborhood: “House Cleaning Services in Pilsen Chicago.”
Comparison content: “Local vs National Cleaning Companies in Chicago: What You Need to Know.”
Case studies: “How We Helped a Pilsen Family Save 40 Hours a Month with Regular Cleaning.”
3) Decision (ready to hire or visit)
Search behavior:
“same day plumber near me”
“emergency electrician Hyde Park Chicago”
“best deep dish in River North”
Content and optimization:
Clear contact info and click-to-call buttons on every page.
“Book now,” “request quote,” or “reserve table” above the fold.
Strong local proof: reviews, testimonials, local photos, and neighborhood mentions.
Practical Local SEO Foundations (Low-Cost, High-Impact)
These are the first moves almost every Chicago business should make.
A. Google Business Profile (GBP): Your Chicago storefront in search
GBP is what shows up in Google Maps and the local pack; it often drives more calls than your website.
Action steps:
Claim and verify your profile if you haven’t already.
Use your real business name (no keyword stuffing).
Make sure your NAP (Name, Address, Phone) matches exactly everywhere (website, Facebook, directories).
Choose the most accurate primary category (e.g., “Plumber,” “Mexican restaurant,” “Accountant”), plus a few relevant secondary categories.
Add a detailed description with neighborhood + service phrases, written naturally.
Example description for a Logan Square plumber:
“We are a family-owned plumbing company serving Logan Square, Avondale, and Humboldt Park in Chicago, specializing in same-day drain cleaning, water heater repair, and emergency plumbing services.”
Use GBP posts weekly:
Share offers, updates, and neighborhood-specific content (“$50 off emergency calls in Logan Square this month”).
Highlight participation in local events, festivals, or neighborhood markets.
B. Reviews: Your most powerful ranking + trust signal
Strong reviews can push a small business above national chains in local results.
Action steps:
Ask every happy customer to review you on Google, Yelp, and key industry sites.
Make it easy: text or email them a direct link right after the service or visit.
Respond to every review—positive and negative—with a calm, human voice.
Tip: Nudge customers to mention neighborhood + service in their own words (never script it).
“They came out to our Wicker Park condo within an hour.”
“Best tacos in Pilsen, hands down.”
C. Local citations and directories
Listings on trusted local sites reinforce that you are a real Chicago business.
Priorities:
Major platforms: Google, Apple Maps, Bing, Yelp, Facebook.
Chicago-focused sites where relevant (e.g., Chamber of Commerce, neighborhood business associations).
Industry platforms (Avvo for attorneys, TripAdvisor and restaurant platforms for restaurants, etc.).
Ensure your NAP is consistent everywhere.
Turning Your Website into a Local Sales Machine
You don’t need a fancy website; you need a clear, trustworthy, local-focused one.
A. Essential pages for most Chicago businesses
At minimum:
Home
Services (separate page for each main service)
About (with local story)
Contact
Neighborhood or service-area pages (more on this below)
FAQ
B. Neighborhood-specific pages (where the long-tail magic happens)
Create a page for each major neighborhood you truly serve.
Examples:
“Plumbing Services in Logan Square Chicago”
“Family-Friendly Restaurant in Wicker Park Chicago”
“Small Business Accounting in Pilsen Chicago”
On each page, include:
A clear headline with the neighborhood: “Trusted Plumber in Logan Square, Chicago.”
A short intro explaining who you serve and what you do in that area.
Specific services with headings that include both the service and area.
Local proof: photos from the neighborhood, testimonials from local customers.
Mentions of nearby landmarks, streets, or transit stops.
C. On-page SEO basics (non-technical)
For each page, especially neighborhood and service pages:
Page title: “Affordable Plumber in Logan Square Chicago | [Business Name].”
Meta description: a human-friendly summary with local keyword and a call to action.
Heading (H1): “Plumbing Services in Logan Square, Chicago.”
URL: “/plumber-logan-square-chicago” or similar.
Use your long-tail phrases naturally in the text—write for humans first.
Example Keyword-to-Page Mapping (Chicago Use Cases)
Here’s how specific businesses can translate keywords into real pages and content.
Restaurants (e.g., Wicker Park, Pilsen, Logan Square)
Keywords: “best tacos Pilsen Chicago,” “family-friendly brunch Wicker Park,” “vegan restaurant Logan Square open late.”
Pages:
“Tacos in Pilsen Chicago”
“Family-Friendly Brunch in Wicker Park”
“Vegan Dinner in Logan Square Chicago”
Content:
Menus with neighborhood + dish names in headings.
Blog posts: “Where to Eat Before a Show at Thalia Hall” (Pilsen) or “Best Date Night Spots in Wicker Park.”
Home services (plumbing, HVAC, cleaning)
Keywords: “emergency plumber in Avondale Chicago,” “Pilsen apartment cleaning service,” “24/7 HVAC repair Near West Side Chicago.”
Pages:
“Emergency Plumbing in Avondale Chicago”
“Move-Out Cleaning in Pilsen Chicago”
Content:
Before/after photos from jobs in those neighborhoods.
Case studies: “How We Fixed a Burst Pipe in a Logan Square 3-Flat in 2 Hours.”
Professional services (law, accounting, therapy)
Keywords: “small business lawyer near Loop Chicago,” “tax accountant in Pilsen for freelancers,” “bilingual therapist in Humboldt Park Chicago.”
Pages:
“Small Business Legal Services in The Loop Chicago”
“Tax Preparation for Freelancers in Pilsen Chicago”
Content:
Guides: “Chicago Sales Tax Basics for Small Retailers.”
FAQs about city-specific rules or neighborhood business realities.
Let’s Elevate Your Business Online
Ready to grow your business with a tailored digital strategy? I partner with companies of all sizes to build personalized digital plans focused on visibility, engagement, and measurable success.
